Craven Hermit’s Top Albums of 2017

Once again, we find ourselves on the precipice of a new year. But before we hang our new calendars and valiantly charge into days of future passed, let’s take a quick look back at the ten albums that brought your Craven Hermit the most enjoyment in 2017. And, as always, feel free to leave your personal Top Ten list in the comments!

It was a fun year for record collecting. Vinyl sales continue to gain momentum, and most of the problems associated with short supply & increasing demand seem to be abating. Plenty of stores are now selling vinyl records, even here in my backwater slice of suburbia. Vinyl release dates seem to be catching up to CD release dates, suggesting to me that some of the manufacturing presses have expanded capacity and/or streamlined their operations. And, if you poke around in enough brick & mortar indie record shops and brave the crowds on Record Store Day, you can find many of your favourite new releases on coloured vinyl. Which may seem like a gimmick to the serious audiophiles that insist that everything other than heavyweight black vinyl is rubbish, but I’ll counter with the belief that music is supposed to be entertaining! I readily admit that seeking out special editions in zany colours is half the fun of collecting. The other half, of course, is actually listening to your new prizes at ludicrous volume!

Let’s see what made the grade for your trusty correspondent this year. Here they are, arranged alphabetically (by artist) on my billiards table in a way that’s vaguely reminiscent of the Star Wars scroll. Go on, Disney – sue me.


Colors by Beck
After teasing us for years with random bits and bytes, everyone’s favourite musical guero finally dropped a complete album on us. Would the chameleonic Beck be in a playful mood, or besotted with broken-hearted misery, or would he perhaps re-inhabit The Purple One’s paisley funk? It turns out that Colors will likely be remembered as Beck’s “summer album”, chock full of pop songs and sun-kissed rhythms. It’s entirely possible that all this exuberance is simply a vacuous veneer over a troubled soul, but hilarious lyrics like “Girl in a bikini with the Lamborghini shih tzu” make it sound like Beck is enjoying the absurdity of life again. Best tracks: “I’m So Free”, “Dreams”, “Wow”

Little Fictions by Elbow
Guy Garvey and co. return with a new batch of songs, minus one original drummer but with a clutch of new ideas. The music is, as always, magisterial and immaculately produced. Garvey’s dissatisfaction with the status quo occasionally creeps in from the margins but Little Fictions, at its core, is a grown-up album dealing with grown-up concerns. The album artwork even evokes the same sort of pastel hues and twilight shadows as the music within. Best tracks: “Magnificent (She Says)”, “Gentle Storm”, “Little Fictions

Beast Epic by Iron & Wine
Sometimes the journey is just as important as the destination. Sam Beam has spent most of the past decade learning how to overlay his quiet folk songs with a kitchen sink of new influences. But just when you might have thought that there were no more ingredients to throw into the sonic stew, he’s ditched the pot altogether, gone back to basics and made what’s essentially a straight-up folk record. The difference between Beast Epic and early works like Our Endless Numbered Days is that the new songs have a melodic depth and structural sophistication that Beam has clearly added to his songwriter’s toolbox along the way. Best tracks: “Thomas County Law”, “Call It Dreaming”, “About a Bruise”

The Hanged Man by Ted Leo
Left for dead without a record contract, Ted Leo embraced Kickstarter to secure the funding for his latest solo venture. Our man Teddy has made a career out of penning what I like to call “exuberantly pissed-off anthems”, and some of those are certainly on display on The Hanged Man. However, Leo’s also used this new lease on life to explore some different sounds and textures. For my money, “Gray Havens” is the best thing he’s written since “The Toro and the Toreador”, unfolding in melodic Mellotronic waves like a long-lost Zombies single. Best tracks: “Used to Believe”, “Gray Havens”, “Lonsdale Avenue”

American Dream by LCD Soundsystem
But they’re dead! We had a funeral at Madison Square Garden for them and everything! Well, yes, that’s true. But before running down the curtains to join the choir invisible, David Bowie reportedly exhorted James Murphy at one of the Blackstar recording sessions to do things that “make him uncomfortable”. And from that, LCD Soundsystem was reborn. American Dream picks up where Murphy and friends left off, with broken disco beats and an often hilarious and weary middle-aged assessment of the musical landscape around them. It’s a brilliant home-on-a-Saturday-night-with-a-bottle-of-wine record. Best tracks: “Other Voices”, “How Do You Sleep?”, “Tonite”

Sleep Well Beast by The National
To be honest, these guys could release sixty minutes of nothing but Jazz Odyssey and police sirens and I would line up on its release day to buy my copy. Then buy it again a few months later when the inevitable “expanded edition” comes out. Fortunately, even when The National tell people they’re making a deliberately fucked-up record, it turns out handsomely. Their stock in trade remains 21st century disillusionment and anxiety, but Sleep Well Beast is spiked with some of the nervous angst that dominated earlier albums like Boxer. “Turtleneck” is probably the closest this band will ever come to recording a proper rocker, and will surely be cathartic on the live stage, but it’s the indelible splendour of songs like “Carin at the Liquor Store” that will follow you into darkened alleys for years to come. Best tracks: “Walk It Back”, “The System Only Dreams in Total Darkness”, “Carin at the Liquor Store”

Hot Thoughts by Spoon
After taking a busman’s holiday with Divine Fits, Britt Daniel returned to his main gig with some exciting new ideas. 2014’s They Want My Soul nudged the classic Spoon template of angular guitars and sinewy drums in different directions, but new album Hot Thoughts pushes the boat out even further from shore. Daniel’s reverb-laden vocals are still accompanied by precision-honed guitar riffs and the incomparable Jim Eno’s snap-tastic drum fills, but now they’re often counter-pointed by electronic snatches of synths. Most intriguingly, in “I Ain’t the One” the chords from a Fender Rhodes hang in the air like ghosts of lost lovers. Spoon’s show at the Winspear Centre in August was also the highlight of my concert year, a masterclass in the possibilities of sleek, beat-driven, modern rock. Best tracks: “Hot Thoughts”, “Can I Sit Next to You”, “I Ain’t the One”

A Deeper Understanding by The War on Drugs
Loads of people are putting this album on their Best of 2017 lists, and with good reason. It’s taken three long years to follow up their excellent Lost in the Dream album, but A Deeper Understanding was well worth the wait. Adam Granduciel and co. still sound like Bryan Adams fronting Dire Straits or the Heartbreakers, but I sincerely mean that in the nicest possible way. These ten widescreen epics unfold at their leisure, comfortable to take the scenic route to their ultimate destinations. Sometimes the wheel doesn’t need to be reinvented, merely perfected. Load this one into the car stereo and drive an hour out of town in any direction. Best tracks: “Up All Night”, “Nothing to Find”, “Thinking of a Place”

Panther in the Dollhouse by Whitehorse
Songwriters Luke Doucet and Melissa McClelland have once again joined forces to pen a new batch of Americana-flavoured adult alternative songs. Their past albums were notable for tunefulness with tasteful restraint, sounding to me like a more polite and introspective Canadian cousin to the Black Keys. So I was pleasantly surprised upon my first spin of Panther in the Dollhouse that the duo has deftly incorporated electronic melodies and modern drum loops into their sound. The new-found sonic seasonings add a dash of excitement to Whitehorse’s always impeccable songcraft. My only gripe is that this is the only album on my Ten Best list that didn’t come with an mp3 download code. Their record company are cheap bastards (just so you know). Best tracks: “Epitaph in Tongues”, “Trophy Wife”, “Pink Kimono”

To The Bone by Steven Wilson
Often I discover artists early in their careers, but once in awhile I stumble across someone in a mid-career purple patch and I have a golden opportunity to work backwards through their body of work. Steven Wilson appeared on my radar by virtue of his brilliant post-production work in recent years for prog stalwarts King Crimson, Jethro Tull, and Rush. I was delighted to discover that Wilson has released a number of albums under his own name, plus a boatload of Porcupine Tree records and a veritable smorgasbord of collaborations. To The Bone is everything that I wish a David Gilmour solo album would be, featuring tasteful guitar solos, intriguing rhythms, and beguiling musical ideas. Constantly engaging, it makes me want to seek out his previous works to see what sort of road led Wilson to this immaculate place. Best tracks: “To The Bone”, “Nowhere Now”, “The Same Asylum

Happy New Year, everyone, and roll on 2018!


3 thoughts on “Craven Hermit’s Top Albums of 2017

  1. Bravo. You done it again with this really nice list! I concur with most of your picks (especially The War on Drugs, Beck, Spoon, and LCD Soundsystem). But mostly I just sit here wishing I could afford to buy as much new vinyl as you do! Here are a few others you might be interested in – they made MY list because they are that good!

    Manchester Orchestra – “A Black Mile To The Surface”. Jaw-dropping gorgeous follow up to what might be one of the greatest albums of this century; 2014’s “Cope”.

    Chris Robinson Brotherhood – “Barefoot In The Head”. If you were ever a Black Crowes fan and have wondered whatever happened to those guys, here is your answer. Front man Chris has a new band and has been cranking out top shelf lightly psychedelic Jam Rock – an album a year for the past five years – since 2012. I own them all but this newest one is perhaps their best yet.

    Willie Nelson – “God’s Problem Child”, Colter Wall – “Colter Wall”, Chris Stapleton – “From A Room Volumes 1 & 2”, Margo Price – “All American Made”, Angaleena Presley – “Wrangled”. It was a very VERY good year for Country music. No, not that Bro Country red solo cup, tight jeans, and a black hat crap. I’m talking REAL country. Sample one or all of these albums and you will be shocked at how most honest emotion, quality storytelling and pure heart still flow through the veins of a cliched genre that, up until very recently, was just a bloated corpse.

    Father John Misty – “Pure Comedy”. If you’re already a fan, no explanation is necessary. If you’re not, no explanation will suffice. This is a flat-out masterpiece and one of the most stunning collections of songs I’ve heard in my entire 52 years, not just in 2017.

    Neil Young – “Hitchhiker”. OK, I’m a big Neil Young fan. I bought this one on VINYL. That should tell you how important it is to me and to Neil’s place in the Rock God pantheon.

    • Well, hello! Glad you dropped by to leave your Best of 2017 list. I’ve had that Manchester Orchestra album on my Amazon wish list for ages – just waiting for it to drop below $50! I’ve been watching the local shops for the new Willie Nelson record, too.

      I came very close to putting the new Jason Isbell record on my Top 10, but I dunno, it’s missing a little something. Perhaps it pales a tiny bit in comparison to Southeastern and Something More Than Free. It’s an excellent record, don’t get me wrong, but perhaps I was expecting something exceptional. Same fate befell the New Pornographers, Noel Gallagher, Neil Finn, Rural Alberta Advantage, and Alt-J. All of them released terrific records in 2017, but I couldn’t make room in my Top 10 for them. Call them the Next 10, I suppose.

      I really enjoyed Fear Fun, but Father John Misty lost me around Honeybear. It was one of those weird records that, the more I listened to it, the more I realized what an insufferable prick he must be in real life 🙂 I’m a pretty jaded and sarcastic fellow, but Father John takes misanthropy to new levels. It’s true when they say that nobody loves a smart-ass. Though I suppose I should at least track down Pure Comedy online and give it a chance. His former comrades in Fleet Foxes, meanwhile, have lost me as well. Their new album has a few spots that I admire, but overall it just sounds so far up its own butt for anyone else to truly enjoy.

      And speaking of insufferable pricks, Neil Young can get bent. I used to admire his songwriting (and on some level, I probably still do), and I was willing to look the other way with his various imperfections. The guy’s a lousy singer, and his band is often out of tune or only vaguely adhering to some semblance of time, but the brief glimpses of musical inspiration were worth it. But after his maddeningly hypocritical tirades about Northern Alberta, he’s dead to me. Hiroshima? Come on.

      I’ve heard good things about Margo Price, so I’ll check that one out. Thanks for the tip!

      • Jason Isbell is a conundrum for me. I was a HUGE Drive-By Truckers fan back about 5 or 10 years ago so I guess I’m obligated to be an Isbell fan. But…other than his two solo masterpieces you mentioned, his work is exasperating because he seems almost schizophrenic – does he want to rock out or does he want to be a sensitive singer-songwriter or does he want to be the next big Alt-Country legend in the Ryan Adams mold? I will keep listening to him because there is serious talent but, like you, I can’t put “Nashville Sound” on my Best Of list.

        “I Love You Honeybear” was my entree to Josh Tillman so I guess I lack the background to judge the guy’s personality. Misanthropic prick or not, the man seems to genuinely care about his species and where it is headed. And, my God, does he makes pretty music. Good call on Fleet Foxes btw. They disappeared up their own asses in 2017. Just so. Their eponymous debut full length is STILL my “Album of the Century” so it pains me greatly to type that…

        Neil Young can indeed get bent. I’m with ya. What he did to his dear long suffering wife of 36 years when he went chasing after Darryl Hannah was unforgivable (and you think Josh Tillman is a prick!!??) and his last 15-20 albums, weird Pono failure, and slew of rambling pot headed books have made me set his career aside for good – in some ways he embodies the worst of everything Boomer Rock Stars represent. HOWEVER. His legacy is unassailable as Canada’s greatest (male that is, Hi Joni!) contribution to Folk & Singer-Songwriter rock music. His first dozen solo albums are among the finest recordings ever created by humankind. It is entirely possible to love a man’s music and NOT love the man. I totally failed to mention that “Hitchhiker” was recorded in 1976 by David Briggs and features just Neil and his acoustic guitar. That makes it “Classic Neil” and not “New Neil”. Does that change anything?

        Margo Price’s debut was better but album #2 is pretty fine. I just wish she’d lighten up on the politics. As DBT learned and Jason Isbell is learning, Country Rock fans don’t want to hear songs about the evil NRA/gun control, pro-immigration policy, minimum wage laws, and white guilt. In fact, if I had to pick one thing that is wrong with popular music today, it’s that it’s totally dominated by a Marxist-Collectivist mindset that pushes a Progressive agenda at the expense and total disregard of traditional social mores, conservative values, and individual autonomy. But that’s the kind of rant I should put on MY blog huh?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s